fbpx

Throughout history, there have been several landmark cases that have shaped the legal landscape in Florida and even the country. Let’s take a look at some of these cases.

Gideon v. Wainwright

In 1961, Clarence Gideon was arrested and charged with breaking and entering Panama City, FL, and couldn’t afford an attorney. The trial judge denied his request to have one appointed so Gideon defended himself and was convicted and sentenced to five years in prison. His appeal to the Florida Supreme Court was denied. In 1963, the U.S. Supreme Court ruled that Gideon had a right to a court-appointed attorney, guaranteed by the Sixth Amendment. At his new trial, with a lawyer, Gideon was found not guilty. This landmark case established that Defendants, who could not afford an attorney, have a Sixth Amendment right to counsel in criminal proceedings.

Anonymous Tip Case (Fourth Amendment violation) – Florida v. J.L.

Dade County Police received an anonymous tip describing three youths at a bus stop, one of whom allegedly carried an illegal concealed weapon. Arriving about six minutes later, police found three youths dressed as the anonymous tipster had described. Police searched the three youths and found the weapon. At the trial, the court suppressed the evidence, but the Third District Court reversed the suppression. The case was appealed to the Supreme Court of Florida. 

The Florida Supreme Court ruled that the police search was unreasonable and violated the Fourth Amendment. The State of Florida appealed to the U.S. Supreme Court. In a unanimous opinion, delivered by Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg, the U.S. Supreme Court agreed with the Florida Supreme Court and held that an anonymous tip, standing alone, that a person is carrying a gun is not sufficient to justify a police officer’s stop and frisk of that person. The Court held that an anonymous tip must possess a level of reliability and credibility as to the informant’s knowledge.

The K-9 Search Case (Fourth Amendment violation) – Florida v. Jardines

Miami-Dade Police Department received an unverified “crime stoppers” tip that a home was being used to grow marijuana. Detectives, along with a trained drug detection dog, approached the front door of the home and the dog signaled that it detected the scent of narcotics. A search warrant was obtained and a search confirmed that marijuana was being grown inside the home. The homeowner moved to suppress the evidence seized at his home arguing that the drug dog’s sniff was an impermissible search under the Fourth Amendment. The trial court ruled to suppress the evidence, but the appellate court reversed the decision. The case went to the U.S. Supreme Court, which held that the front porch of a home (“the curtilage”) is part of the home itself, and a dog sniff within the curtilage, without a warrant, constitutes a search for Fourth Amendment purposes.

Firm Overview

Gans Law offers a variety of services that range from criminal defense to suspended licenses. Here at Gans Law, we understand that sometimes good people find themselves dealing with complex legal matters.

Learn More

Case Results

Our Reviews

Serving all of central Florida

Orange

Hillsborough

Osceola

Brevard

Seminole

Polk

Volusia

Pinellas

Can a Petitioner Violate a Restraining Order in Florida?

In Florida, a restraining order is a protective order designed to safeguard individuals from threats, harassment, or abuse. The order is typically issued against a respondent, the individual accused of the behavior, to protect the petitioner. Restraining orders are...

Resisting Arrest With and Without Violence in Florida

Whenever you encounter law enforcement and they go to arrest you, it is never a good idea to resist them as you can get into more trouble. If you resist arrest with violence, you’ll face even higher penalties.   Resisting Without Violence According to Florida Statute...

Florida Traffic Tickets and Your Driving Record

When you get pulled over for a moving violation, you may wonder what is going to happen to your driving record. Is it something that prospective employers can see? If you decide to fight a traffic ticket, either by taking it to court yourself or hiring an attorney,...

Why is being on probation more dangerous than you think?

When facing potential jail time, most defendants prefer to be placed on probation instead of going to jail. Probation comes with many stipulations that many defendants fail to consider. Before accepting an offer of probation, consider the following:  Florida Statute...

Misdemeanors and Felony Charges in Florida

Felonies and Misdemeanors differ in both the severity of the crime and of the penalties. Misdemeanors tend to be less severe crimes, so the punishments for these crimes tend to be lesser. The fines are relatively small, and you can only be held in jail for up to a...

What is the Penalty for First-Time DUI in Florida?

Driving Under the Influence (DUI), often referred to as “drunk driving,” is when a driver of a motor vehicle has a blood alcohol content (BAC) over the legal limit, or their normal faculties are impaired by drugs or alcohol.  A DUI conviction in Florida comes with...

What is Disorderly Conduct?

In Florida, disorderly conduct is any behavior that disrupts a public space. Some common examples include making excessively loud noise, drunk and disorderly behavior, and fighting in the street. Florida Statute 877.03 defines disorderly conduct as acts that are of a...

Can You Lose Your License for Leaving the Scene of an Accident?

Under Florida law, it is a criminal offense for leaving the scene of an accident. Florida Statute 316.061 states that leaving the scene of an accident, also known as a “hit and run,” occurs when the driver of the vehicle involved in a crash resulting in damage to...

New Florida Law: Playing Loud or Excessive Music

On July 1, 2022, a Florida law went into effect that prohibits excessive music and other sounds from being played inside the vehicle. According to Florida Statute 316.3045, it is unlawful for any person operating or occupying a motor vehicle on a street or highway to...

What’s the Difference Between Assault & Battery in Florida?

Although assault and battery offenses in Florida are similar and are discussed together, they are two distinct criminal offenses. In Florida, the main difference between assault and battery is the absence or presence of physical contact. Assault is a verbal or...

News & Posts

FAQs

Trivia

Orlando, FL

711 N. Orlando Ave. Suite 302B, Maitland, FL 32751

Hours: By Appointment Only

Clearwater, FL

8200 Bryan Dairy Road Suite 340
Largo, FL 33777

Hours: By Appointment Only

407-500-4267

Send Us a Message!

More Contact Info

// // "UPixel" code from roger@printingwarehouses.com //